Abstract
Abstract. This paper illustrates the relationship between energy reforms and economic sustainable development in Egypt and Iran; through analyzing the relation between energy reform and four main macroeconomic variables, namely: budget deficit, energy consumption, inflation and economic growth. The methodology adopted in this paper is a comparative case study between Egypt and Iran, using qualitative descriptive analysis; focusing on the period from 2010 to 2014, as this period is characterized with active subsidy reform efforts for both countries. The paper concludes that reforming energy subsidies generally tends to relief the strain on the public budget, in case it is not accompanied with simultaneous economic difficulties which can deem the reform efforts obsolete, like in the case of Iran. In addition, the responsiveness of energy consumption of a certain fuel to the increase in its price is heavily reliant on its price elasticity of demand. This is represented in the availability of alternative energy sources. Moreover, the effect of the reforms on inflation is normally instantaneous and short-lived and could be mitigated through government intervention; that was clear in the case of Egypt. However, Iran did not show a similar trend as there was a weak correlation between subsidy reforms and inflation. Finally, there tends to be a very weak relationship between subsidy reforms and GDP growth, implying that the effect of other economic factors outweighs that of subsidy reforms.
Keywords. Energy subsidy reform, MENA region, Sustainable development.
JEL. E62, H23, Q01.
References
Abouleinein, S., El Laithy, H., & Kheir-El-Din, H. (2009). The impact of phasing out subsidies of petroleum energy products in Egypt, Working Paper No.145. [Retrieved from].
Basiago, A.D. (1998). Economic, social, and environmental sustainability in development theory and urban planning practice. Environmentalist, 19(2), 145-161. doi. 10.1023/a:1006697118620
Besada, H.G., & Olender, M. (2015). Fossil Fuel Subsidies and Sustainable Energy for All: The Governance Reform Debate. Global Governance, 21(1), 79-98. doi. 10.1163/19426720-02101007
Birol, F., El-Katiri, L., Fattouh, B., Henderson, J., Levin, R., Narwani, S., … Tobin, D. (2012). A Quarterly Journal for Debating Energy Issues and Policies (Issue 88). [Retrieved from].
British Petroleum Statistical Review, (2015). BP Statistical review of World Energy [Data file]. [Retrieved from].
Castel, V. (2012). Reforming Energy Subsidies in Egypt. AfDB, [Retrieved from].
Clarke, K. (2014). Egypt’s Recent Subsidy Reforms. AfDB, [Retrieved from].
Daily News Egypt, (2014). 90% of energy subsidies to be lifted within 3 years: Finance minister. Retrieved 18 Nov. 2015, from Daily News Egypt. [Retrieved from].
Demirkol, O., Blotevogel, R., Zytek, R., Zimand, P. & Liu, Y. (2014). Islamic State of Iran- selected issue, Country Report Paper, No.14/94. [Retrieved from].
Earth Policy Institute, (2011). Data Center [Data file]. from Earth Policy Institute. 20 April 2016. [Retrieved from].
ENID, (2012). Subsidies and the Social Safety Net in Egypt, Policy Brief, No.012. [Retrieved from].
El-Katiri, L. & Fattouh, B. (2015). A Brief Political Economy of Energy Subsidies in the Middle East and North Africa. [Retrieved from].
Ellis, J. (2010). The Effects of Fossil-Fuel Subsidy Reform: A review of modelling and empirical studies. [Retrieved from].
Esfahan, (2014). Cut those subsidies. Retrieved 18 Nov. 2015, Economist. [Retrieved from].
Fattouh, B., & El-Katiri, L. (2012). Arab Human Development Report: Energy Subsidies in the Arab World. [Retrieved from].
Griffin, P., Thomas, L., & Robertson, J. (2016). Guiding Reform of Energy Subsidies Long-Term, Policy Research Working Paper, No.7571. [Retrieved from].
Guillaume, D.R., Zytek, R. & Farzin, M.R. (2011). Iran–The Chronicles of the Subsidy Reform, Working Paper, No.WP/11/167. [Retrieved from].
Hamid, K.A., & Rashid, Z.A. (2012). Economic Impacts of Subsidy Rationalization Malaysia. In Y. Wu, X. Shi, & F. Kimura (eds). Energy Market Integration in East Asia: theories, electricity sector and subsidies (pp.207-252). Jakarta: ERIA Research Project Report. [Retrieved from].
Harris, J.M. (2003). Sustainability and sustainable development. International Society for Ecological Economics, 1-12. [Retrieved from].
Hassanzadeh, E. (2012). Recent Developments in Iran’s Energy Subsidy Reforms, Policy Brief. [Retrieved from].
IEA, OECD & World Bank (2010). The Scope of Fossil-Fuel subsidies in 2009 and a Roadmap for Phasing out Fossil-Fuel Subsidies(An IEA, OECD & World Bank Joint Report prepared for the G-20 Summit: Seoul, Republic of Korea). [Retrieved from].
IEA, OPEC, OECD, and World Bank, (2010). Analysis of the Scope of Energy Subsidies and Suggestions for the G-20 initiative. An IEA, OPEC, OECD, and World Bank joint report prepared for submission to the G-20 Summit Meeting: Toronto, Canada. [Retrieved from].
International Monetary Fund, (2013). Energy subsidy reform: lessons and implications. [Retrieved from].
International Monetary Fund, (2015). Counting the Costs of Energy Subsidies. [Retrieved from].
Khattab, A. S. (2008). The Impact of Reducing Energy Subsidies on Energy Intensive Industries in Egypt. In H. Kheir-El-Din (Ed.), The Egyptian Economy: Current Challenges and Future Prospects (pp. 263-299). Cairo, Egypt: American University in Cairo Press. [Retrieved from].
Krosinsky, K. (2013). Sustainable Options for Alleviating Energy Poverty in SubSaharan Africa: A Theoretical Evaluation of Community-led Renewable Energy Development. Brussels Journal of International Studies, 10, 106-143.
Lechtenbohmer, S., Prantner, M., Seifried, D., Supersberger, N., Moshiri, S., Atabi, F., … & Massarrat, M. (2010). Development of three cornerstones for a sustainable energy future in Iran, Work Package 2. [Retrieved from].
Loris, N. (2013). The Wind Production Tax Credit and the Case for Ending all Energy Subsidies. Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum, 23, 323-349. [Retrieved from].
Ministry of Finance, (2008). Oil and Energy Profiles in Egypt. [Retrieved from].
Ministry of Finance, (2015). Egypt’s five year macroeconomic framework and strategy. [Retrieved from].
Mourad, M. (2015). Egypt considers postponing fuel subsidy smart card system - state media. 18 Nov. 2015, [Retrieved from].
Mourougane, A. (2010). Phasing out energy subsidies in Indonesia (Working paper No. 808). Retrieved 4 Nov. 2015, from Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. [Retrieved from].
Munasinghe, M. (2004). Sustainomics: A Trans-disciplinary Framework for Making Development More Sustainable. International Society for Ecological Economics. Research Gate database. [Retrieved from].
Nikou, S.N. & Glenn, C. (2015). The Subsidies Conundrum. Retrieved 27 Nov. 2015, from United States Institute of Peace. [Retrieved from].
Regional Economic Outlook, (2015). Regional Economic Outlook: Middle East and Central Asia. Washington D.C, USA: International Monetary Fund publications.
Rizk, M. (2014). Egypt premier defends steep rise in energy prices. Retrieved 18 Nov. 2015, from US News. [Retrieved from].
Robin, S., Wolcott, R., & Quintela, C.E. (2003). Perverse Subsidies and the Implications for Biodiversity: A review of recent findings and the status of policy reforms. In 5th IUCN World Park Congress: Durban, South Africa. Retrieved from Research Gate database. [Retrieved from].
Salehi-Isfahani, D., Stucki, B.W., & Deutschmann, J. (2015). The reform of energy subsidies in Iran: The role of cash transfers. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, 51(6), 1144-1162. doi. 10.1080/1540496x.2015.1080512
Saunders, M., & Schneider, K. (2000). Removing energy subsidies in developing and transition Economies. Paper presented at the 23rd Annual IAEE International Conference. Sydney, Australia: Australian Bureau of Agriculture & Resource Economics. [Retrieved from].
Sdralevich, C., Sab, R., Zouhar, Y. & Albertin, G. (2014). Subsidy Reform in the Middle East and North Africa Recent Progress and Challenges Ahead. [Retrieved from].
United Nations Environment Programme, (2008). Reforming Energy Subsidies: Opportunities to Contribute to the Climate Change Agenda. [Retrieved from].
World Bank, (2011). Arab Republic of Egypt Poverty in Egypt 2008-09: Withstanding the Global Economic Crisis (Report No. 60249-EG). [Retrieved from].
World Bank, (2016). DataBank [Data file]. World Bank, 21 Feb. 2016. [Retrieved from].
World Energy Outlook, (2015). Energy subsidies [Data file]. International Energy Agency. 23 Feb. 2016. [Retrieved from].
Zayed, D. (2014). Egypt: Slashed fuel subsidies stir discontent. All Africa. 18 Nov. 2015, [Retrieved from].